Puerto Rico Islanders 1:1 Columbus Crew 20 10월 2009 · CONCACAF Champions League 2009/10, Final tournament, Preliminary Round
Cruz Azul 2:0 Puerto Rico Islanders 29 9월 2009 · CONCACAF Champions League 2009/10, Final tournament, Preliminary Round
Puerto Rico Islanders 1:1 Saprissa 22 9월 2009 · CONCACAF Champions League 2009/10, Final tournament, Preliminary Round