Lanús 6:0 Gimnasia y Esgrima La Plata 28 9월 1958 · Argentine Primera Division 1958, Primera, First Round
Newell's Old Boys 1:0 Gimnasia y Esgrima La Plata 19 10월 1958 · Argentine Primera Division 1958, Primera, First Round
Racing Club 4:1 Newell's Old Boys 12 10월 1958 · Argentine Primera Division 1958, Primera, First Round
Central Córdoba 0:2 Newell's Old Boys 04 10월 1958 · Argentine Primera Division 1958, Primera, First Round
Newell's Old Boys 1:1 Rosario Central 28 9월 1958 · Argentine Primera Division 1958, Primera, First Round
Huracán Buenos Aires 4:0 Newell's Old Boys 21 9월 1958 · Argentine Primera Division 1958, Primera, First Round